RealWomen Reviews

MENOPAUSE · HONEST REVIEWS

Reader Story

I Tried 10 Different Menopause Joint Supplements. Only One Actually Worked.

Two years, a kitchen cupboard full of bottles and probably $1,500 later, here's my honest verdict on each one, so you don't have to waste the money I did.

By Debra K., 58

Retired school teacher · Columbus, Ohio · 8 min read

About a year after my periods stopped, my body started falling apart.

First it was my hips. I couldn't lie on either side without a burning ache waking me up. Then my knees on the stairs. Then my fingers in the morning, so stiff I couldn't open a jar. My doctor did an X-ray, said everything looked "fine", and told me it was probably just age.

I was 56. I didn't feel ready to be "just age".

So I did what every woman I know does. I started buying supplements. A lot of them.

My actual kitchen table last spring. My husband called it "the pharmacy".

Here's every single one I tried, roughly in order, and what happened.

1. Glucosamine & Chondroitin

The first thing the pharmacist suggested. I took it faithfully for three months. Maybe my knees felt slightly less creaky? I honestly couldn't tell. My hips didn't change at all.

Verdict: Nothing I could feel.

2. Collagen Powder

Everyone on Facebook swore by it. I stirred it into my coffee every morning for four months. My nails got stronger, and that's it. My joints didn't care.

Verdict: Great nails, same pain.

3. Fish Oil

I already took one a day, so I doubled it. Fishy burps, no difference. I later read you'd need a huge dose for joints, way more than the bottle says.

Verdict: Not strong enough.

4. Supermarket Turmeric

This one did something. The sharp flares were a little calmer. But the deep ache in my hips never moved. Months later I read the label properly and saw it wasn't standardized for anything. It was basically kitchen spice in a capsule.

Verdict: A tiny bit of help. Not enough.

5. Magnesium

Helped me sleep a little better, which was nice. But I was still waking up at 2am because of my hip.

Verdict: Good for sleep, not for joints.

The stairs at night were my worst enemy.

6. Vitamin D

My blood test said I was a bit low, so I took it. Probably good for my bones long-term, but zero change to the pain.

Verdict: Worth taking anyway, but no relief.

7. Evening Primrose Oil

A friend took it for hot flashes and suggested it. Maybe it helped my mood a bit. My joints, no.

Verdict: Not for joint pain.

8. Black Cohosh

This is the "menopause herb" everyone mentions. It took the edge off my night sweats, but it's not designed for joints, and it didn't help them.

Verdict: Hot flashes, maybe. Joints, no.

9. CBD Gummies

Expensive. Made me a bit drowsy. The pain was still there, I just cared slightly less about it for an hour.

Verdict: Not worth the price.

The moment it clicked

By this point I'd basically given up. Then I came across a short video from an OB/GYN that stopped me in my tracks. She said joint pain that starts around menopause is very often an estrogen problem, not an "age" problem.

Estrogen keeps your tendons and joint tissue hydrated and supple. When it drops, everything dries out and stiffens, especially the hips.

That's when I realized why nothing had worked. I'd spent two years treating the pain and never once touched the cause.

10. She Again

The OB/GYN talked about a plant called moringa, which is naturally rich in phytoestrogens, plant compounds that help your body balance estrogen naturally. She said most moringa sold online is too weak to do anything, and recommended a menopause formula called She Again, which uses a proper dose of the strongest variety.

It also has 95% curcumin. When I compared that to my old supermarket turmeric, it explained a lot.

I'll be honest, I bought it expecting to be disappointed for the tenth time.

Week 1–2: Nothing dramatic, but the morning stiffness in my fingers felt a bit softer.

Week 3: I realized I'd slept through the night. Then I did it again the next night.

Week 5: I walked up the stairs carrying the laundry basket without stopping halfway. My husband actually noticed before I did.

Now: I'm sleeping on my side again. I'm back to my morning walks. And I picked up my grandson and swung him round in the garden without thinking twice.

This was the moment I knew it was working.

Verdict: The only one that actually worked, because it was the only one going after the real cause.

What I wish someone had told me two years ago

If your joint pain started around menopause, you're probably not dealing with a "joint" problem. You're dealing with an estrogen problem. Glucosamine, collagen and painkillers can't fix that.

I threw out the other nine bottles. The only one left in my cupboard now is She Again.

If you're where I was, please don't spend two years and $1,500 like I did. Nova, the company that makes it, has a 60-day money-back guarantee, so you can try it without risking anything. This is the one I use.

— Debra

#1 of the 10 I tried

Try She Again Risk-Free

Moringa to rebalance estrogen at the root, plus 95% curcumin for the aches you feel today.

✓

Made for women in menopause with joint pain

✓

60-day money-back guarantee. Try it, and if it doesn't help, get your money back.

Check Today's Sale Price →

60-Day Money-Back Guarantee · Hormone-free · Made in small batches

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Individual results may vary.

This article reflects one person's experience and is not medical advice. Talk to your healthcare provider before starting a new supplement.